Tastiest Ice Cream Sandwich in the World!

The winner was one I didn't even know existed. I must now try their top 3 in order to vet their choices.

Epi Top Pick: Turkey Hill Vanilla Bean Ice Cream Sandwich ($3.99 for a box of six)

Pros: The creamy ice cream with real vanilla flavor and the moist, spongy cakelike cookie won raves from the testers. "The ice cream is so fluffy and smooth!" said one editor. "The vanilla specks are not just for show, the ice cream tastes like it's made with a real vanilla pod; very natural," said another.

Cons: Thin in comparison to other competitors.

It certainly looks pretty damn tasty to me. This pic is from their web page: